Big Pete's New York Style Pizzeria on 5th Street. Big Pete's couldn't make a go of the location that was formerly a Pizza Hut. While Big Pete's has way better pizza than Pizza Hut, something about the location might be at play. Pizza Hut still has locations all over the country and Big Pete's still has it's original North Town Arcata location on G St. where business is booming.
I am a big fan of pizza especially New York Style. It is a thin delicious pizza one can pick up and eat. The thick Chicago pizza pies were something I liked when I was young but I have outgrown those. If you're like me and love New York Style pizza but live in Eureka instead of Arcata you're in luck. Paul's Live From New York has just opened a second location and it is in Eureka at 6th. and F Street. Paul's Live From New York has been in McKinleyville for years now so I wish them luck in Eureka.